"You're so beautiful that I forgot my pick up line."
No, because I'm sure that you didn't, because this is your pick up line. If you have to mention having a pick up line in the message, the message itself is a pick up line.
And I can't be all that that beautiful to you because of the fact that I'm wearing a Blackhawks jersey in my profile picture and he's wearing a Blues jersey. Personally, I would date a Blues fan, but only if they were sincere and accepting. But most hockey fans are die hard, and most guys who are hockey fans aren't as accepting of others as most girls. I actually have been told by no less than 3 guys through my adventures who were Blues fans that the main reason that I was being rejected by them was in quotes "You're a filthy Blackhawks fan." One guy is normal, two is coincidence, and three or more is a trend.
Which is the reason I have my profile pic in my Blackhawks jersey. This way I can weed out the deadbeats and rude people from the real guys. And also let them know that I'm sports fan who happens to be a girl, and not just a girl sports fan. That difference is another post entirely.
Like most girls, I want to be told I'm beautiful because it's honestly how the guy feels. Not as a pick up line. And until recently, I haven't ever been told I was beautiful.